AI Can Build a Website, But Should It?

AI website builders are the peanut butter-and-jelly of digital convenience:  fast, cheap, and easy to understand. The appeal is obvious. Need a site? Click a few buttons, fill in some boxes, and bam - you’ve got yourself a website. Feel like a tech wizard yet?

These platforms are popping up like mushrooms after heavy rain, with promises of sleek designs and cutting-edge functionality. For many business owners, the DIY dream of "I built it myself!" is intoxicating. There’s a sense of pride in creating something without help.

But from our personal experience, we’ve seen a number of these AI-designed projects come to us recently that honestly make us twitch. The sad part? These clients are so proud of what they’ve accomplished with AI that they don’t realize how much their designs are missing the mark. It’s a tough conversation to have, but one that’s necessary to truly help their business thrive.

We agree, AI makes tasks easier and more efficient when used correctly. However, while AI is impressive, it’s not magic.

And it's not always right.

---

 

Key Takeaways:

• AI websites can be fast and affordable, but they often fall short.
• DIY AI-designed sites may lack optimization capabilities.
• Content created by AI often fails to convert visitors into customers.
• Poor design from AI websites can harm your business's credibility.
• Relying too much on AI could cost you customers, visibility, and long-term ROI.

---

 

What AI Can Do Well (Fair Is Fair)

Before we roast AI website builders completely, let's give credit where credit is due. These tools can be handy for certain tasks:

• Generate ideas and copy quickly – Think “starter text,” not Shakespeare. AI tools are great for brainstorming and getting your first draft done, but don’t expect them to replace the nuance and creativity of a human writer. With the right prompt (details about your target customer, buying signals, brand voice, tone, style, and product or service information), AI can generate compelling, tailored website content that resonates with your audience - with a little guidance from a personalized human touch.
• Provide sleek design templates – They look good… at first glance. Many design tools offer templates that are visually appealing and can give your projects a polished, professional look right out of the gate. However, these templates often lack the flexibility needed to fully align with your brand’s unique style, voice, and identity. Customizing them beyond the basics can be challenging, leaving your design feeling generic or mismatched with your overall branding.
• Offer basic layouts and visuals – Great if you're okay with just "basic." These tools are great for creating functional designs quickly and with minimal effort, making them a popular choice for beginners or those on tight deadlines. But if you’re aiming for something truly unique, custom, and visually striking that stands out from the competition, you may find these basic layouts and visuals too limiting. A truly standout design often requires more advanced tools or a professional touch to go beyond the cookie-cutter appearance.
• Deliver some beginner-level SEO help – Enough to get you started but not enough to thrive. Many platforms include basic SEO features, like keyword suggestions and simple site optimization tools, which can help you rank for less competitive keywords and get a foothold online. However, if you’re aiming to compete in a crowded digital space or target highly competitive search terms, these beginner-level tools won’t cut it. Achieving real, sustained growth requires a more robust, tailored SEO strategy and ongoing optimizations to respond to changes in search engine algorithms.

Bonus tip? AI can be a fantastic helper in the right hands. For instance, we use it to fast-track research, streamline repetitive tasks, and spark creativity for our clients. (AI isn’t evil - when you know how to use it wisely.)

What AI Can’t Do (And Why That’s a Problem)

Now the tricky bit. Here’s where AI website builders fall short and where your business ends up paying the price:

1. Choose the Right Platform

From site speed to scalability to SEO strategy, the platform you pick can make or break your site’s performance. AI doesn’t consider long-term functionality, growth, or your specific business needs; it only cares about delivering a site now. The wrong platform could mean slow loading speeds, limited scalability as your business grows, or poor performance on search engines, all of which can hurt your brand and bottom line.

2. Build SEO-Friendly Structures

What about URL optimization, internal linking, schema markup? These are the building blocks of a site that ranks well on search engines. AI-built websites rarely prioritize these critical elements. Without proper SEO structures, your site may look decent but remain invisible to your target audience, making it harder to attract organic traffic.

3. Handle Technical Challenges

Think page speed, mobile usability, and indexing. A slow-loading site drives users away faster than anything else, and poor mobile performance is a death sentence in today’s mobile-first world. AI-generated sites often neglect these critical technical details, leaving you with a website that struggles to perform and frustrates your visitors before they even get to know you.

4. Guide User Journey and Boost Conversions

User flow, lead funnels, calls-to-action...these aren’t just buzzwords; they’re the backbone of a website that converts. AI might be able to lay out pages, but it lacks the human touch needed to design a website that intuitively guides users, builds trust, and encourages them to take action, whether that’s making a purchase, signing up for a newsletter, or contacting your team. This process is even more important as overall organic traffic drops (due to AI Mode answering questions and reducing the need for clicks), a trend that is shining the spotlight even brighter on the importance of quality conversions. 

5. Ensure Proper Integrations

CRMs, analytics tools, ad tracking systems, email platforms...getting these tools to work seamlessly with your website requires expertise. AI website builders often fail to integrate these systems properly, leaving you with a site that lacks the functionality needed to track performance, engage with customers, or manage data effectively.

Here’s the bottom line: AI can get you a basic site quickly, but if you’re looking for a high-performing website that drives traffic, engages visitors, and boosts conversions, you’ll need more than pre-built templates and generic solutions. It takes strategy, creativity, and technical expertise to build a website that truly works for your business. Don’t settle for “good enough”. Invest in a site that can grow with you and deliver real results.

Real Talk: Why DIY AI Sites Hurt Your Business

Look, we get it. Budget-friendly solutions are tempting, especially for small businesses trying to make every dollar count. But sometimes, the “cheap and quick” route ends up costing you more - in time, money, and missed opportunities. DIY site builders using AI might seem like a smart choice upfront, but here’s why they often backfire:

• You’re Invisible on Search Engines – Poor SEO and a flimsy site structure mean search engines can’t find or rank your pages properly. Without visibility, your business is buried under competitors who invested in professional design and SEO strategies.
• You’re Driving Customers Away – A clunky, unattractive design instantly screams “unprofessional” to potential customers. If your site is slow, confusing, or unappealing, visitors won’t stick around; they’ll bounce straight to your competitors’ sites.
• You Don’t Know What’s Working – DIY platforms rarely provide in-depth analytics tools to track performance. Are visitors converting into customers? Are you ranking in search results for key terms? Without real data, you’re left guessing while losing valuable insights.
• You’re Paying Twice – Sure, it seems like a deal upfront, but when your DIY site fails to deliver results, you’ll end up hiring a professional to fix it or rebuild it entirely. That means spending extra money and starting from scratch.

Cutting corners with a DIY AI site might save you time now, but it can hurt your business in the long run. Investing in a professionally built site is an investment in your growth, credibility, and success.

The Legal Implications of AI-Generated Content

Using AI to create content can feel like having a super-efficient assistant, but it’s not without its legal gray areas. Copyright issues, for example, can spring up faster than you can say “machine learning.” Many AI tools generate content based on huge datasets, and if those datasets include copyrighted material, you could inadvertently end up using content that belongs to someone else. Then there’s the matter of accountability—if AI produces misleading or defamatory content, who’s liable? You guessed it, the buck stops with you. Ensuring that your AI-generated content is both original and legally compliant is like walking a tightrope, but it’s crucial to protect your business and brand.

What a Professional Website Team Brings to the Table

Here’s where the pros come in to save the day. Building a site isn’t just about slapping pretty pages together. It’s about creating a digital experience that drives results. A professional team brings strategy, optimization, and flawless execution to the table to ensure your site doesn’t just look good but works hard for your business.

• Strategic Planning – Your website should do more than exist; it should work for you. Pros create a tailored strategy that aligns with your audience, sales funnels, and business goals, ensuring every feature and page has a purpose.
• SEO Superpowers – Great websites are search-engine friendly from the start. With SEO baked into the site’s architecture and content from day one, your website is primed to rank higher, drive traffic, and bring in the right audience.
• Brand-Consistent Design – A great site doesn’t just grab attention; it keeps users engaged. Professionals ensure your design reflects your brand, builds trust, and guides users effectively, turning visitors into leads with seamless navigation and compelling visuals.
• Custom Integrations – Your business tools need to work together effortlessly. From CRMs to analytics and e-commerce platforms, pros handle backend integrations to make sure your site runs like a well-oiled machine, saving you time and frustration.
• Ongoing Support & Testing – Once your site is live, the work doesn’t stop. A professional team watches for traffic drops, conversion dips, or issues and adjusts in real time to keep your site performing at its best. Regular updates and testing ensure your site stays secure, optimized, and ahead of the curve.

With professionals on your side, your website becomes more than an online presence—it becomes a powerful tool for growth.

Web Developers Pro Checklist:

Curious what a professionally built site offers that DIY with AI often skips?

• UX-optimized designs
• Scalability for future growth
• Advanced analytics and tracking
• Robust SEO foundations
• CRM and ad campaign integration
  
  

Conclusion: AI Is a Tool—Not a Replacement

AI website builders are tools. They serve a purpose, but they’re far from foolproof. If your website is the digital face of your business, this is not the place to pinch pennies or play amateur designer.

Websites that perform, websites that grow your business, are built with strategy, expertise, and a human touch. After all, trust isn’t instant, conversions aren’t accidents, and no bot is going to understand your audience’s needs like a professional will.

Not sure if your AI site is helping or hurting? We’ll take a look for free. Reach out today, and we’ll show you how to turn your website into a real business-growth machine.